This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Howdy & happy Tuesday, PA readers new and old. Shout out to those of you who caught a spaceship from orbit on Saturday.

IN THIS WEEK’S EDITION:
🌪️ A timeline in turmoil (and the week ahead)
🌐 Brownfield, greenfield, and the new map
🇺🇸 American drones: “Gradually, then suddenly”
📰 News Parsed, plus The Spruce Goose

Forwarded this? Join Per Aspera today.

00 Timeline + Calendar

It feels fair to say that the timeline has been in nonstop turmoil these last couple of weeks. To wit…

  • Thursday: Jensen Huang stepped down as CEO of Nvidia, raising a lot of questions for a company that has more or less become the central bank of the AI buildout. Oh, and Microsoft 365 went down for most of a day.

  • Friday: The FAA stopped every departure for more than four hours, with cancellations that ran through the weekend. Ryan narrowly made it back to Texas before the ground stop. Crusey, at the very same airport and about to board an international flight, wasn’t as lucky. Further south, SpaceX launched Starship Flight 15 from Starbase.

  • Saturday: We got a feature finish, when SpaceX brought Ship 42 back to the tower from orbit, the first time any ship has been caught.

  • Sunday: ULA's Vulcan lifted off carrying 40 Amazon Leo satellites and suffered an anomaly about ten minutes into flight, losing the payload. It was the rocket's first flight since a February booster problem, and it takes America's launch situation for anyone not named SpaceX from bad to worse.

  • Monday: Yesterday rolled around with a bad case of the Mondays for Chase and Wells Fargo and United Airlines.

And as for this week… the show goes on.

  • Today + tomorrow: As we speak, TomorrowX has taken over the Moody Center in Austin (which normally hosts the Texas Longhorns basketball teams and singers like Madonna, Bruce Springsteen, Willie Nelson, Bad Bunny, and SZA). Try to picture 5,000+ institutional investors, Fortune 500 CEOs, and self-professed “s***posters” of X all convening under one giant roof amid intense market jitters around AI. And, in a few short hours, Nvidia reports earnings.

  • Wednesday: Voyager 1, the little spacecraft that could, will pass one light-day from Earth (16B miles) tomorrow at 5:16 am ET. Investors will probably care more about what the Fed has to say when it publishes minutes from its October meeting, as a nervous market looks for hints on where rates go next.

  • Thursday: Rockstar’s GTA VI finally ships… and Anthropic is expected to start trading. Plan for engineering productivity impediments accordingly.

  • Friday: ??? Hopefully the internet still works?

On a more serious note, we’ve seen at least five outages in five days. Folks have been quick to pick a culprit: a state-sponsored cyberattack, AI, or an AI-powered cyberattack. So far, nobody has pinned any of it on any of those. Microsoft, the FAA, Chase, and United each blamed their own software or hardware and say they’ve seen no sign of an attack (though the FAA’s investigation is still ongoing).

That may well be the whole story. It’s also hard to know much of anything in the first few days, when theories travel a lot faster than root-cause reports. But it’s as good a reminder as any that we need to focus more on securing our critical infrastructure and that, actually, plenty of devices, systems, and sensors don’t need to be connected to the internet at all. (More on that below.)

There’s a foundry in Kutztown, Pennsylvania that has been pouring metal since 1866. By 2018, it was near death, with just two employees. Yesterday, Hadrian bought the foundry and pledged $300M to upgrade it as Factory 6, casting naval-grade steel for Virginia- and Columbia-class submarines.

This got us thinking about greenfield vs. brownfield… so we mapped 11 American defense and industrial plants announced, started, or opened since July. Sure enough, six are going up on old military or industrial ground:

  • Middletown, IA: The Army set up the Iowa Ordnance Plant here in 1940, and at its World War II peak it employed 13,000 people. In July, Czech-owned MSM broke ground inside it on a 155mm line rated for 36,000 shells a month (#065).

  • Sparrows Point, MD: Once the largest steel mill in the world, it's now the site of Anduril's $6.6B Arsenal-2 yard for Virginia-class parts (#066).

  • Camden, AR: The Navy started building rockets here in 1945. On Oct. 20, L3Harris opened a solid rocket motor plant in town built to double its capacity.

  • Grand Prairie, TX: Along with Kutztown, Hadrian is dropping a 24-machine cell inside Lockheed's existing missile plant (#067).

  • Sullivan County, IN: AEP, X-energy and Amazon are studying 12 small reactors on the site of a retired coal plant.

Old sites tend to come with the zoning, the rail, and the power and water already hooked up. They also come with supplier density, the clustering effects of an industrial town, and the tribal knowledge a new owner-operator needs to carry the torch forward. Even for a shop that differentiates on highly automated processes (Exhibit A: Hadrian), tribal knowledge is still a critical ingredient.

Whether it’s new transmission on existing right-of-way (#065), or uprating existing nuclear plants (#066), this is a trend you can’t unsee once you notice it: Use what you have! Sometimes that may be enough as a stopgap solution. But for fabs, first-of-a-kind plants, and the like, greenfield will still be the only way.

Widening the aperture a tad, nothing is putting the U.S. defense industrial base to the test quite like munitions and missiles. Suppliers are being called on to ramp production as the U.S. replenishes stocks drawn down in overseas conflicts.

  • Just yesterday, Senate appropriators unveiled a nearly $1.1T defense bill that moves $40B+ of extra munitions money out of the administration’s reconciliation bill and into the base budget, and the line items are enormous.

  • Army missile procurement goes from a $12.1B request to $37.9B. PAC-3 MSE alone goes from $1.3B to $12.2B, THAAD from $0.9B to $11.4B, and the Navy’s SM-6 line from $0.7B to $4.3B.

  • The new guard has also arrived: Crusey/IceNine-backed Castelion’s Blackbeard (#066) goes from zero in the request to $631M, alongside several hundred million more for low-cost cruise missiles and containerized munitions.

All anyone can talk about on the flying robot front is drones that are bound for the battlefield. We come bearing good news from the civilian/commercial fronts, too!

Zipline’s founders started out building an iPhone-controlled toy robot. When that company shut down in 2014, they turned to fixed-wing drones and set up on a cow farm, working from trailers to keep engineering, manufacturing, and flight test together. Within a couple of years, they were flying blood to 21 hospitals in Rwanda. Earlier this month, Zipline raised $1.5B at a $21.5B valuation, nearly triple its January price, and signed Walmart for 300 more delivery sites.

Zipline is what great engineering and perseverance look like, with a David-vs.-Goliath twist thrown in for good measure. Early on, it had to talk investors into backing it while Amazon, Alphabet, and even Uber funded drone delivery programs with their fortress balance sheets. CEO Keller Rinaudo Cliffton says VCs didn’t think Zipline was “investable” for its first 10 years, and that the venti-corn (just go with it) almost died just two years ago!

  • The startup had a clever, if inadvertent, GTM “trick”: it took on life-saving blood and medicine delivery sorties for rural African clinics, where it had an undeniable edge over the status quo (inadequate road networks). It used that foothold to mature the technology, rack up flight hours, and build an unassailable safety case for a drone-hesitant FAA.

  • Ryan was thinking about drones back during the pandemic… and, as he wrote in 2020: “Don’t sleep on Zipline.” Six years later, Zipline counts 3M+ deliveries and 150M autonomous miles without an incident, and says its medical flights help save 14,000+ lives a year.

  • In a full-circle moment, the State Department is paying to triple Zipline’s African network, in what we consider savvy counter-Belt-&-Road dealmaking: an up-to-$150M pay-for-performance contract, matched by up to $400M in fees from African governments, to reach as many as 15,000 health facilities and 130M people.

And that’s not all…

Skydio’s new F10 Lightrunner is lopsided by design: the camera sits out on one wingtip, so the wing never blocks its view. Engineers lengthened that wing and offset the motors to balance it. It flies up to 100 mph and ships next year.

  • Skydio: Axon has put $1.2B into the drone maker at a $5.2B pre-money valuation and become its exclusive public-safety distributor in the U.S. and Canada. Skydio now counts 1,500+ customers, many of them police and fire departments that send a drone to a 911 call ahead of a first officer. Two years ago, Beijing’s sanctions had the company rationing customers to one battery per drone (#034). It has bounced back, and then some.

  • Wing: Alphabet’s drone unit, born at X in 2012, has committed up to $125M over two years to U.S. manufacturing, anchored by a Fort Worth plant sized for 10,000s of aircraft a year. Wing has made 1M+ home deliveries this year from 70+ sites and is contracted to reach 270+ Walmart stores by 2027.

Zipline has made 1M+ deliveries in DFW alone this year. Wing and Amazon are flying there today, too. Like robotaxis, drone delivery is arriving gradually, then suddenly.

001 // BAAJA BLAST… Congress is closer to passing major permitting reform than it’s been in two decades. Yesterday, the Senate voted 70-27 to end debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a week after voting 73-25 to take it up, and a final vote is expected before Thanksgiving. The permitting bill, from Sens. Shelley Moore Capito, Mike Lee, Martin Heinrich, and Sheldon Whitehouse, would cut the window to sue over a federal environmental review from six years to 150 days, let FERC permit a major transmission line if a state sits on the application for a year, and make data centers pay for the grid upgrades they trigger. Permitting is extremely unsexy, and extremely important to how big projects get built and financed in the U.S. Backers like Arnold Ventures call it “the most important affordability legislation in a generation.” Here’s a good primer on the bill.

002 // COLD CHAIN x CYBER… For an outage where somebody definitely did break in, we go to the cold chain. On Oct. 11-12, hackers got into the refrigeration controllers at ~700 French supermarkets and switched on the defrost cycles, spoiling fresh/frozen food and setting some equipment on fire. Last week, France blamed a cyber unit tied to Iran’s Revolutionary Guards, summoned Tehran’s ambassador, and said it would push for sanctions at the European level. On Nov. 2, the same thing happened at 115+ stores across Belgium, the Netherlands, Sweden, Luxembourg, Ireland, and Estonia. A refrigeration vendor says it was the same hole exploited in France a month earlier, but investigators haven’t yet attributed the attack. Washington isn’t waiting to find out: CISA, the FBI, HHS, USDA, and DOT have told American operators to get refrigeration controllers off the public internet, change the default passwords, and cap how far a setpoint can be moved. The Pentagon had already been looking into similar incidents at U.S. base commissaries in August.

The U.S. has 16 specified critical infrastructure sectors, whose physical security and cybersecurity are essential to national security, the economy, and public health and safety.

003 // HONEY, WAKE UP, NEW HANDMER POST JUST DROPPED… Casey Handmer’s latest blog, “Where does Baumol bite?”, asks where the value actually accrues from this year’s projected ~$720B of AI capex. He looks at the topic through the lens of Baumol’s cost disease: the parts of an economy that can’t get more productive end up soaking up a growing share of spending. His contention: chips, models, and batteries are all produced in volume at factories, so their margins will eventually be competed away. The rent will migrate to what can’t be stamped out: power, land, permits, and the tradespeople who build. (Longtime readers will recognize the supercycle’s “second-order winners,” a running PA theme since #025.) By decade’s end, Casey figures, tokens will price near the cost of electricity and silicon. An excellent read, as is customary from Casey, who by day runs Terraform Industries. (Speaking of capex: SemiAnalysis, long the most bullish forecaster on AI, has slashed its 2028 AI accelerator projections by 28%.)

And now, for a lighter palate cleanser… Some 79 years ago, Howard Hughes took the H-4 Hercules out on Long Beach Harbor for what was billed as a day of taxi tests. Four reporters on the scene left to file their stories after the first two runs.

But on the third try, Hughes lifted the thing about 70 feet off the water and flew it roughly a mile at 135 mph. The "Spruce Goose" (a critic's nickname) was almost all birch, built with Hughes's Duramold process because wartime aluminum was spoken for, and while it never flew again, its ~320-foot wingspan remained the widest ever flown until Stratolaunch in 2019.

Hmm. The media predetermining failure for a new technology? Declaring that it would surely never fly? Can we think of any other times that’s happened?

Why, yes, we can. In October 1903, the NYT figured a working flying machine was one million to ten million years off. The Wright brothers flew at Kitty Hawk 69 days later. In 1920, the same paper lectured Robert Goddard that a rocket couldn’t work in a vacuum, then ran a correction in July 1969, the day after Apollo 11 launched. And we’ve seen it again in our own time, with every Starship test flight that got written up as a failure on the way to Saturday’s historic catch.

Here’s to the builders who don’t let it get into their heads too much (and to the critics who stay for the last run and correct the record).

With that, your PA crew is signing off. See you back here next week.

X logo LinkedIn logo Instagram logo Mail icon
PER ASPERA IS FOR PEOPLE WITH OBSESSIVE DRIVE AND ENDLESS PSYCHE TO PURSUE HARD THINGS.